Frontotemporal dementia (FTD), the second most common cause of dementia in people under 65, may be triggered by a defect in immune cells called microglia that causes them to consume the brain’s synaptic connections, according to new research led by UCSF scientists.
The new study – published April 21, 2016 in the journal Cell — adds to growing evidence that the brain’s immune system is a driving force behind many neurodegenerative diseases, and suggests new approaches to diagnosing and treating patients with FTD, which currently affects as many as 22 out of 100,000 adults, with typical onset between the ages of 45 and 65.
Microglia normally act as the brain’s garbage collectors, disposing of foreign particles such as viruses or bacteria as well as sick and dying brain cells. In the developing brain, microglia also help refine the brain’s circuitry by pruning back unneeded neural connections, which are marked for destruction with immune molecules called “complement proteins.” Recent studies by Harvard neurobiologist Beth Stevens, PhD, and others have suggested that this process may go awry during adolescence in patients with schizophrenia, and as a side effect of aging in patients with Alzheimer’s disease: in both cases an overabundance of complement protein appears to cause too many synapses to be tagged for destruction by the microglia.
“The brain’s innate immune system is emerging as a common pathway behind many neurodegenerative disorders,” said senior author Eric Huang, MD, PhD, a professor of pathology at UCSF and pathologist at the UCSF-affiliated San Francisco VA Medical Center. “This idea has been controversial, however, because in human patients, neurodegeneration is typically accompanied by some degree of inflammation, with lots of activated microglia, but it’s hard to tell whether that is a driver of the degeneration or a consequence. You need careful experiments using animals models to dissect the cause-effect relationship.” In Mice, Gene Mutation Causes FTD-Like Symptoms
Working with colleagues at UCSF’s Memory and Aging Center and departments of Neurology and Neurological Surgery, as well as the UCSF-affiliated Gladstone Institutes, Stanford University, and others, Huang and his team compared brain tissue from human FTD patients with familial mutations in the progranulin gene to the brains of mice with this gene deleted. In the mice, the defect caused age-related neurodegeneration and excessive grooming akin to the obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) symptoms seen in human FTD patients.
The researchers found that as the mice aged, the mutation caused a gradual breakdown of microglial cells’ waste disposal systems, which led to excessive activation of these cells’ aggressive immune functions, heightened production of complement proteins, and excessive synaptic pruning in the thalamus, a part of the brain that is highly relevant to human FTD.
Additional experiments on isolated microglia made it clear to the researchers that progranulin normally acts as a brake to prevent excessive microglia activation. Without it, it appeared that an unknown aspect of the normal aging process allowed microglia to spiral out of control.
However, the researchers showed that they could short-circuit this death spiral by deleting the gene for one of the major complement proteins produced by microglia, called C1qa. Mice with both the progranulin and the C1qa genes turned off lived considerably longer than those with intact C1qa, and didn’t develop OCD-like behaviors. Their brains also showed a drastic reduction in the number of activated microglia and much better protection from synapse loss.
“We worked for more than two years to get to that result,” Huang said, “But when we did, it was a really surreal experience. It was immediately clear that blocking complement protein might be a good therapeutic target for FTD patients with progranulin mutations.” Research Points to New Approaches for Dementia Patients
Huang and his team are now collaborating with a biotech company called Annexon to test therapies that block C1qa. However, these treatments are likely still a long way off. For one thing, treatments for neurodegeneration likely need to be taken early, before the brain damage is done, and there’s still no way to reliably detect the disease before it’s far too late.
That’s why the researchers also investigated whether the elevated complement protein levels that would be predicted by their study show up in patients’ cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) — the fluid collected by a spinal tap. If so, they could potentially serve as a biomarker to allow early detection of the disease.
Initially they were disappointed by the results: “We looked at CSF from normal and diseased brains side by side, and they looked about the same,” Huang said. “But then we tried separating the FTD patients based on how severe their dementia had been when the CSF samples were taken, and the result was really spectacular. Clearly, as patients’ mental status declined, the level of complement protein in their CSF increased.”
Huang says he hopes future research will allow physicians to use this signal to enable earlier diagnosis and to test the effectiveness of potential treatments. If doctors give an anti-complement drug and the levels of complement protein in the CSF go down, he said, that would be a good sign that the immediate danger to the brain has been relieved.
About this neurology research
UCSF researchers on the paper include lead author Hansen Lui; as well as Jiashen Zhang, PhD; Stefanie Makinson, PhD; Michelle Cahill; Kevin Kelley, BS; Hsin-Yi Huang, MD, PhD; Yulei Shang, PhD; Michael Oldham, PhD; Christine Hsieh, PhD; Charles Kim, PhD; Bill Seeley, MD; Anna Karydas; Bruce Miller, MD; and Jeanne Paz, PhD. Other authors on the paper are at FORUM Pharmaceuticals; UCLA; Stanford University School of Medicine; Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine; the Mayo Clinic; the University of British Columbia and Vancouver General Hospital; the University of Brescia; the IRCCS Istituto Centro San Giovanni di Dio, Fatebenefratelli; Harvard University; and the San Francisco VA Medical Center.
Funding: The research was supported by the National Institutes of Health (grants AG013854, P50 AG023501, P01 AG019724, P30 AI027763 and P30 DK063720), the Italian Ministry of Health, the JPB Foundation, the Department of Veterans Affairs (Career Development Award-2 and Merit Awards BX002690, BX001108 and RX002133), the Consortium for Frontotemporal Dementia Research (CFR) and the Bluefield Project.
Source: Nicholas Weiler – UCSF Image Source: The image is in the public domain. Original Research:Abstract for “Progranulin Deficiency Promotes Circuit-Specific Synaptic Pruning by Microglia via Complement Activation” by Hansen Lui, Jiasheng Zhang, Stefanie R. Makinson, Michelle K. Cahill, Kevin W. Kelley, Hsin-Yi Huang, Yulei Shang, Michael C. Oldham, Lauren Herl Martens, Fuying Gao, Giovanni Coppola, Steven A. Sloan, Christine L. Hsieh, Charles C. Kim, Eileen H. Bigio, Sandra Weintraub, Marek-Marsel Mesulam, Rosa Rademakers, Ian R. Mackenzie, William W. Seeley, Anna Karydas, Bruce L. Miller, Barbara Borroni, Roberta Ghidoni, Robert V. Farese Jr., Jeanne T. Paz, Ben A. Barres, and Eric J. Huang in Cell. Published online April 21 2016 doi:10.1016/j.cell.2016.04.001
Progranulin Deficiency Promotes Circuit-Specific Synaptic Pruning by Microglia via Complement Activation
Highlights •Progranulin regulates lysosomal function and complements production in microglia •Grn−/− microglia preferentially eliminates inhibitory synapse in ventral thalamus •Grn−/− mice exhibit hyperexcitability in ventral thalamus and OCD-like behaviors •Loss of C1qa mitigates neurodegeneration and improves survival in Grn−/− mice
Summary Microglia maintain homeostasis in the brain, but whether aberrant microglial activation can cause neurodegeneration remains controversial. Here, we use transcriptome profiling to demonstrate that deficiency in frontotemporal dementia (FTD) gene progranulin (Grn) leads to an age-dependent, progressive upregulation of lysosomal and innate immunity genes, increased complement production, and enhanced synaptic pruning in microglia. During aging, Grn−/− mice show profound microglia infiltration and preferential elimination of inhibitory synapses in the ventral thalamus, which lead to hyperexcitability in the thalamocortical circuits and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)-like grooming behaviors. Remarkably, deleting C1qa gene significantly reduces synaptic pruning by Grn−/− microglia and mitigates neurodegeneration, behavioral phenotypes, and premature mortality in Grn−/− mice. Together, our results uncover a previously unrecognized role of progranulin in suppressing aberrant microglia activation during aging. These results represent an important conceptual advance that complement activation and microglia-mediated synaptic pruning are major drivers, rather than consequences, of neurodegeneration caused by progranulin deficiency.
“Progranulin Deficiency Promotes Circuit-Specific Synaptic Pruning by Microglia via Complement Activation” by Hansen Lui, Jiasheng Zhang, Stefanie R. Makinson, Michelle K. Cahill, Kevin W. Kelley, Hsin-Yi Huang, Yulei Shang, Michael C. Oldham, Lauren Herl Martens, Fuying Gao, Giovanni Coppola, Steven A. Sloan, Christine L. Hsieh, Charles C. Kim, Eileen H. Bigio, Sandra Weintraub, Marek-Marsel Mesulam, Rosa Rademakers, Ian R. Mackenzie, William W. Seeley, Anna Karydas, Bruce L. Miller, Barbara Borroni, Roberta Ghidoni, Robert V. Farese Jr., Jeanne T. Paz, Ben A. Barres, and Eric J. Huang in Cell. Published online April 21 2016 doi:10.1016/j.cell.2016.04.001