Summary: The severity of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease is linked to the degree to which the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases enzyme is relaxed or extended.
Source: Scripps Research Institute
Treatments have been hard to pinpoint for a rare neurological disease called Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT), in part because so many variations of the condition exist. So far, mutations on more than 90 genes have been positively linked to the disorder; a patient needs just one of those mutations for the disease to emerge.
Regardless of which genetic mutation is present, CMT universally inflicts damage on patients’ peripheral nervous system, which extends from the spinal cord into the hands and feet. For that reason, patients often experience difficulties with balance, walking and fine motor skills, such as buttoning a shirt.
“The genetic mutations of CMT are well understood, but the disease-causing mechanisms are still a mystery on a molecular and cellular level,” says Scripps Research Professor Xiang-Lei Yang, PhD, who led the research. “In our latest study, we took a bottom-up approach, looking for commonalities among different mutations in one of these genes in the hope that we will uncover new insights for treatment.”
In research that appears in the journal PNAS, Yang and her team focused on ubiquitous enzymes known as aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. These enzymes are not only Yang’s long-running research specialty, but also the largest protein family linked to CMT disease. Pervasive throughout the body, these enzymes attach to the appropriate amino acids to kick off the first step of making new proteins. Considering that proteins are the building blocks of everything from blood and hormones to skin and bones, this process is central to human life.
Yang says that earlier research, which examined the mutated enzymes independent of other biology, had shown that the disease-affected aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases didn’t work as well as their healthy counterparts. In the scientific world, this is known as a “loss of function.”
But using patient samples and viewing the enzymes in their natural cellular environment, Yang’s lab found something different: Any loss of function disappeared when the mutated enzymes were paired with other healthy enzymes that exist within a cell. The finding makes sense, she says, as CMT would be far more severe if this enzyme’s crucial biological function was amiss.
But if there was no loss of function, how were these mutated enzymes implicated in disease? That was the next question Yang sought to answer. For this line of inquiry, she looked at shape rather than function.
Using biochemical and biophysical analysis tools, Yang and her team discovered that the mutated enzymes took on an unusual extended shape. This is unlike their healthy counterparts, which have a more compact design with far less exposed surface.
“The extra surface area may create unwanted interactions with nearby proteins, and these interactions could be what leads to a diseased state,” Yang says. In fact, further study showed that disease severity is likely linked with the degree to which the enzyme’s shape was relaxed or extended.
As her next step of research, Yang plans to delve more deeply into the connection between different forms of CMT, which may lead to general strategies for treating the disease. Her motivation, in addition to a scientist’s need for understanding, are CMT patients and their families–many of whom have personally reached out to her.
“One in 2,500 people have CMT, and today there is no therapy available to help them,” Yang says. “We believe the best path to a treatment is to start by understanding what is fundamentally wrong in the biological environment of this complex neurodegenerative disease.”
Authors of the study, “CMT disease severity correlates with mutation-induced open conformation of histidyl-tRNA synthetase, not aminoacylation loss, in patient cells,” are David Blocquel, Litao Sun, Zaneta Matuszek, Sheng Li, Thomas Weber, Bernhard Kuhle, Grace Kooi, Na Wei, Jonathan Baets, Tao Pan, Paul Schimmel, and Xiang-Lei Yang.
Funding: This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health [Grant R01 GM088278] and a fellowship from National Foundation for Cancer Research.
Scripps Research Institute
Kelly Quigley – Scripps Research Institute
The image is credited to the Martin family.
Original Research: Closed access
“CMT disease severity correlates with mutation-induced open conformation of histidyl-tRNA synthetase, not aminoacylation loss, in patient cells”. David Blocquel, Litao Sun, Zaneta Matuszek, Sheng Li, Thomas Weber, Bernhard Kuhle, Grace Kooi, Na Wei, Jonathan Baets, Tao Pan, Paul Schimmel, and Xiang-Lei Yang.
CMT disease severity correlates with mutation-induced open conformation of histidyl-tRNA synthetase, not aminoacylation loss, in patient cells
Aminoacyl-transfer RNA (tRNA) synthetases (aaRSs) are the largest protein family causatively linked to neurodegenerative Charcot–Marie–Tooth (CMT) disease. Dominant mutations cause the disease, and studies of CMT disease-causing mutant glycyl-tRNA synthetase (GlyRS) and tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (TyrRS) showed their mutations create neomorphic structures consistent with a gain-of-function mechanism. In contrast, based on a haploid yeast model, loss of aminoacylation function was reported for CMT disease mutants in histidyl-tRNA synthetase (HisRS). However, neither that nor prior work of any CMT disease-causing aaRS investigated the aminoacylation status of tRNAs in the cellular milieu of actual patients. Using an assay that interrogated aminoacylation levels in patient cells, we investigated a HisRS-linked CMT disease family with the most severe disease phenotype. Strikingly, no difference in charged tRNA levels between normal and diseased family members was found. In confirmation, recombinant versions of 4 other HisRS CMT disease-causing mutants showed no correlation between activity loss in vitro and severity of phenotype in vivo. Indeed, a mutation having the most detrimental impact on activity was associated with a mild disease phenotype. In further work, using 3 independent biophysical analyses, structural opening (relaxation) of mutant HisRSs at the dimer interface best correlated with disease severity. In fact, the HisRS mutation in the severely afflicted patient family caused the largest degree of structural relaxation. These data suggest that HisRS-linked CMT disease arises from open conformation-induced mechanisms distinct from loss of aminoacylation.