Summary: Children raised in disadvantaged neighborhoods may show blunted brain responses to rewards and losses, especially if they have a family history of depression. New research reveals that community-level stress, not just personal trauma, can dampen neural reactions tied to motivation and emotional engagement.
This muted response may contribute to higher depression risk, as children learn to disengage emotionally in chronically stressful environments. The findings underscore how neighborhood factors shape mental health and highlight the need to consider community context when addressing depression risk.
Key Facts:
- Blunted Brain Response: Children from disadvantaged areas showed reduced neural activity to rewards and losses, especially if already at risk for depression.
- Community Stress Matters: Stress from the environment—not only personal experiences—may influence brain development related to emotional and motivational responses.
- Broader Implications: Neighborhood conditions can impact children’s mental health even without direct exposure to specific traumas.
Source: Binghamton University
Children who grow up in disadvantaged neighborhoods – areas with higher levels of crime and deprivation, and lower access to community resources – are at risk of developing depression and new research led by faculty at Binghamton University, State University of New York, may help to explain why.
Psychologists at Binghamton found that the brains of children from areas containing higher levels of deprivation show less response to reward and loss, but only if they were already at risk for depression based on a family history of the disorder.
The team included Binghamton University Professor of Psychology Brandon Gibb, graduate student Elana Israel and former graduate students Cope Feurer and Aliona Tsypes.
“One of my interests is how neural reward processing relates to risk for depression. One thing that we know that impacts that is exposure to stress,” said Israel.
“Prior research has looked at stress at the individual level – people reporting on traumas they’ve experienced or interpersonal stress – but less research has looked at community-level stressors.”
To examine this, the team conducted a study of over 200 children ages 7-11. The researchers conducted interviews to determine if their parent had a history of major depressive disorder.
They also collected each child’s zip code, which provided information about their neighborhood such as risk of crime, levels of socioeconomic disadvantage, and more.
The researchers then measured the brain activity of each child via electroencephalogram (EEG) while they completed a simple guessing task where they won or lost money.
Examining the data, the researchers found that children from more disadvantaged areas showed a blunted response to both reward and loss, especially children of parents with a history of depression.
“When something good or bad happens to you, your brain responds and we can measure that brain activity,” said Gibb. “And how you tend to respond to something good happening or something bad happening can increase your risk for things like depression.
What this shows is that it’s not just something happening to you personally, but it’s the context you live in — the levels of stress around you, whether or not it’s directly happening to you.”
Gibb said that growing up in a chronically stressful environment, children may learn not to get too excited when good things happen and not to get too down when bad things happen, especially if they are already at risk because of a family history of depression.
“When you’re chronically stressed, it could dampen your reaction to anything, whether it is good or bad,” said Gibb.
“We want kids to be reactive when good things are happening. You should be excited. That’s what gives you the motivation to engage and do things. So that’s what we think is going on.”
Going forward, the researchers have started a new study that will let them look at what happens to children’s neural responses, and depression risk, when they move to a new neighborhood.
The team also wants to expand this work to teenagers and see if similar types of effects are seen for social rather than just monetary outcomes, like peer acceptance and rejection.
Gibb said that this work highlights the need to address neighborhood characteristics when it comes to mental health.
“Just being in these contexts can impact mental health, and these neighborhood characteristics can influence kids, even if they’re not touched by it directly. So there are broader implications too, and even more reasons why we should try to improve our communities.”
About this depression and neurodevelopment research news
Author: John Brhel
Source: Binghamton University
Contact: John Brhel – Binghamton University
Image: The image is credited to Neuroscience News
Original Research: Closed access.
“Parental History of Major Depressive Disorder Moderates the Relation Between Neighborhood Disadvantage and Reward Responsiveness in Children” by Brandon Gibb et al. Research on Child and Adolescent Psychopathology
Abstract
Parental History of Major Depressive Disorder Moderates the Relation Between Neighborhood Disadvantage and Reward Responsiveness in Children
In this study, we examined associations between census-derived indices of neighborhood disadvantage and children’s reward outcome processing and whether these relations would be stronger among children already at risk for alterations in reward processing due to having a parental history of major depressive disorder (MDD) compared to children of never depressed parents.
Participants were 224 children aged 7–11 years old and their parent. Parents were required to either have a history of MDD or no lifetime history of any depressive disorder.
To measure reward outcome processing, we focused on the reward positivity (RewP) event-related potential (ERP) elicited following gain and loss outcome feedback while children completed a monetary reward task.
Census-derived measures of neighborhood disadvantage based upon families’ addresses included the Area Deprivation Index (ADI), neighborhood crime risk, and the Child Opportunity Index (COI).
The general pattern of findings across indices was that higher levels of neighborhood disadvantage were associated with more blunted neural reactivity to both gain and loss feedback, but only among children with a parental history of MDD and not among children of never depressed parents.
These results suggest that broader contextual stressors may impact how youth process reward outcome feedback, especially youth already at heightened risk for depression, which may have implications for understanding risk for disorders associated with reward dysfunction.
