Further Evidence World Trade Center Responders Are at Risk for Dementia

Summary: First responders at the World Trade Center have reduced cortical gray matter thickness, which was consistent with neurodegenerative conditions and evidence their brain age is, on average, ten years older than those of similar ages in the general population.

Source: Stony Brook University

Two studies led by Stony Brook University researchers to be presented virtually at the Alzheimer’s Association International Conference on July 28, 2020, indicate that World Trade Center (WTC) first responders are at risk for developing dementia. The studies included individuals with signs of cognitive impairment (CI) who show neuroradiological abnormalities and changes in their blood similar to that seen in Alzheimer’s disease patients and those with related dementias.

One study in Alzheimer’s and Dementia: Diagnosis, Assessment and Disease Monitoring (DADM) shows that many responders with CI have reduced gray matter thickness in the brain consistent with neurodegenerative conditions and evidence their brain “age” is about 10 years older on average than the normal population. This research is in collaboration with scientists at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai.

The other study, to be published in Translational Psychiatry, reveals some responders with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and mild CI possess protein changes in their blood consistent with Alzheimer’s.

“The environmental exposures and psychological pressures experienced by responders during 911 and its aftermath has had an insidious effect on their health and well-being,” says Benjamin Luft, MD, Director of the Stony Brook WTC Health and Wellness Program. “Now nearly 20 years post-911, clinicians who care for these individuals are seeing more patients who are showing signs of cognitive disorders and possible dementia. Findings from our new studies provide data for the first time that support the idea that this population of patients who have cognitive impairment not only have psychological problems such as PTSD but may be at high-risk for neurodegenerative disorders, a possibility that needs immediate and continued investigation.”

One study is the first to use MRI imaging to assess the brain matter of WTC responder patients with and without symptoms of CI. The goal of this study is to determine if WTC responders in their midlife have developed CI due to changes in their brain possibly caused by neurotoxins they were exposed to at Ground Zero. The age range of patients was 45 to 65 years, an age range where cortical atrophy is rare in the normal population.

Researchers measured the brain cortex, the area responsible for cognition. Cortical thickness is a consistent measure of brain atrophy commonly used in studies of patients with Alzheimer’s and related dementias. Imaging revealed areas of the cortex are atrophied in many WTC patients with cognitive impairment, compared to control subjects.

“While there are many reasons for cognitive decline because of brain changes, the loss of gray matter in the brain is one of the most concerning and can be measured by cortical thickness,” explains Sean Clouston, PhD, lead author and Associate Professor of Family, Population and Preventive Medicine and in the Program in Public Health. “We found a direct correlation between those suffering from cognitive impairment and cortical thickness, indicating a reduction in gray matter of the brain at levels consistent with neurodegenerative disease.”

The overall amount of cortical atrophy in responders with CI was significantly more than responders who did not have CI symptoms, as well as to the general population based on normative data.

According to the authors, the MRI imaging revealed that cortical thickness was significantly reduced in 23 out of 34 cortical regions among those with CI. These included the frontal, temporal and occipital lobes. When compared to published data, both responders with CI and those without CI showed significant reductions in cortical thickness in seven regions in or near the temporal lobe potentially indicative of a population-level effect.

Dr. Clouston said that the level of reduction in the cortical thickness in many responders is similar to that in patients with dementia and is “a possible indicator of early stage dementia with possible early onset dementia likely to occur for a portion of these individuals at midlife.”

However, he explains that these patients need to be studied longitudinally to determine whether these changes progress over time. Additional imaging and other related brain research is also necessary to determine the cause or causes of brain atrophy in WTC responders.

The second study describes an analysis of 276 proteins in the blood in 181 WTC male responders in midlife – their average age 55 years.

Each of the identified proteins are instrumental to a range of processes indicative of neurological diseases, cellular regulation, immunology, cardiovascular, inflammatory, developmental and metabolism functions.

This shows brain scans from the study
These brain images are a compilation of MRI results from WTC responders. The images show gray matter atrophy on the brain, with yellow and red areas revealing statistically significant atrophy compared to the normal population. Red areas show worse atrophy than yellow. Image is credited to Stony Brook University.

Given that PTSD and mild CI are common to 911 responders – which affect their cognitive and memory processes – individuals with these conditions were studied.

By using a sophisticated process that identifies dysregulation of proteins among the 276 identified for the study, the researchers found that WTC responders with mild CI also had proteinopathy, or problematic changes in the proteome, consistent with Alzheimer’s and related diseases as well as other neuropsychiatric conditions.

“We believe that neuro-inflammation is a possible mechanism in which responders with PTSD appear to be at a higher risk of developing mild cognitive impairment,” said Dr. Luft, senior author. “We hope our unique analysis of proteins associated with cognitive impairment-related diseases in this population is an additional way to identify their risk based on changes in their body likely due from their exposures.”

Funding: The studies were supported by the National Institute for Safety and Occupational Health (NIOSH) and the National Institute on Aging (NIH grant number R01AG049953).

About this dementia research article

Stony Brook University
Media Contacts:
Greg Filiano – Stony Brook University
Image Source:
The image is credited to Stony Brook University.

Original Research: Open access
“Reduced cortical thickness in World Trade Center responders with cognitive impairment”. by Sean A. P. Clouston Yael Deri Megan Horton Cheuk Tang Erica Diminich Christine DeLorenzo Minos Kritikos Alison C. Pellecchia Stephanie Santiago‐Michels Melissa A. Carr Samuel Gandy Mary Sano Evelyn J. Bromet Roberto G. Lucchini Benjamin J. Luft. Alzheimer’s & Dementia: Diagnosis, Assessment & Disease Monitoring.


Reduced cortical thickness in World Trade Center responders with cognitive impairment

This study examined cortical thickness (CTX) in World Trade Center (WTC) responders with cognitive impairment (CI).

WTC responders (N = 99) with/without CI, recruited from an epidemiologic study, completed a T1‐MPRAGE protocol. CTX was automatically computed in 34 regions of interest. Region‐based and surface‐based morphometry examined CTX in CI versus unimpaired responders. CTX was automatically computed in 34 regions of interest. Region‐based measures were also compared to published norms.

Participants were 55.8 (SD = 0.52) years old; 48 had CI. Compared to unimpaired responders, global mean CTX was reduced in CI and across 21/34 cortical subregions. Surface‐based analyses revealed reduced CTX across frontal, temporal, and parietal lobes when adjusting for multiple comparisons. Both CI and unimpaired WTC groups had reduced CTX in the entorhinal and temporal cortices compared to published normative data.

Results from the first structural magnetic resonance imaging study in WTC responders identified reduced CTX consistent with a neurodegenerative disease of unknown etiology.

Join our Newsletter
I agree to have my personal information transferred to AWeber for Neuroscience Newsletter ( more information )
Sign up to receive our recent neuroscience headlines and summaries sent to your email once a day, totally free.
We hate spam and only use your email to contact you about newsletters. You can cancel your subscription any time.