Memory Replay Prioritizes High Reward Memories

Why do we remember some events, places and things, but not others? Our brains prioritize rewarding memories over others, and reinforce them by replaying them when we are at rest, according to new research from the University of California, Davis, Center for Neuroscience, published Feb. 11 in the journal Neuron.

“Rewards help you remember things, because you want future rewards,” said Professor Charan Ranganath, a UC Davis neuroscientist and senior author on the paper. “The brain prioritizes memories that are going to be useful for future decisions.”

It’s estimated that we only retain detailed memories for a small proportion of the events of each day, Ranganath said. People with very detailed memories become overwhelmed with information. So if the brain is going to filter information and decide what to remember, it makes sense to save those memories that might be most important for obtaining rewards in the future.

Ranganath and postdoctoral researcher Matthias Gruber put this to the test by scanning the brains of volunteers by functional magnetic resonance imaging as they answered simple yes-no questions on short series of objects — for example, “do these objects weigh more than a basketball?” Each series of objects was shown on a background image for context, and depending on the context, the volunteers were told they would either get a large (dollars) or small (cents) reward for giving correct answers. At the end of a series, participants were told how much money they just won.

Once participants completed this part of the experiment, the volunteers were scanned during a resting period. Afterward, outside of the scanner, there was a surprise memory test for all objects that were shown during scanning.

Although participants were not expecting the memory test outside the scanner, they were better at remembering objects that were associated with a high reward, said Gruber, first author of the paper.

“Also, when an object was associated with high reward, people remembered better the particular background scene that was on the screen during scanning,” Gruber said.

Memory could be biased toward high points of experience

Even more interesting, participants’ memory performance was predicted by brain activity measured during rest. When the researchers looked at brain scans of subjects at rest after giving yes-no answers — neither learning nor actively recalling the memory — they found the same pattern of activity as when subjects were doing the high-reward task. The subjects were apparently replaying the rewarding memories, strengthening connections and helping to fix the memory in place.

Image shows an MRI scan with the hippocampus highlighted and a basketball court.
Why do we particularly remember the high points of experience? Using functional MRI, UC Davis neuroscientists were able to able to identify a signal in the hippocampus associated with a rewarding memory, in this case related to a photo of a basketball court. Credit: Charan Ranganath.

People who showed more replay of high-reward memories showed better retention of these events during the post-scan test, as well as increased interactions between the hippocampus, a structure deep in the brain heavily involved in memory, and an area called the substantia nigra/ventral tegmental area complex, which is involved in reward processing, suggesting that reward played a role in stimulating the hippocampus after learning.

Although this study did not measure it directly, these interactions were likely related to release of dopamine, a neurotransmitter that is released in the brain when we expect rewards. Conditions such as Parkinson’s disease or aging are linked to reduced dopamine and often involve memory defects.

The results show how memory could be biased toward the high points of experience, Ranganath said. “It speaks to a memory process that is normally hidden from us,” Ranganath said. “Are you remembering what you really need to know? It could depend on what your brain does while you are at rest.”

About this memory research

Co-authors on the study were Maureen Ritchey, Shao-Fang Wang and Manoj Doss, all at the UC Davis Center for Neuroscience.

Funding: The work was supported by multiple sources including the Office of Naval Research, NIH, the Guggenheim Foundation, a Parke-Davis Fellowship and the German Research Foundation.

Source: Andy Fell – UC Davis
Image Source: The image is credited to Charan Ranganath.
Original Research: Abstract for “Post-learning Hippocampal Dynamics Promote Preferential Retention of Rewarding Events” by Matthias J. Gruber, Maureen Ritchey, Shao-Fang Wang, Manoj K. Doss, and Charan Ranganath in Neuron. Published online February 11 2016 doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2016.01.017


Abstract

Post-learning Hippocampal Dynamics Promote Preferential Retention of Rewarding Events

Highlights
•We tested the effect of reward motivation during learning on post-learning dynamics
•Post-learning SN/VTA-hippocampal functional connectivity predicted memory benefits
•Reactivation of hippocampal activity patterns also predicted memory benefits
•Post-learning dynamics and encoding activity were independently related to memory

Summary
Reward motivation is known to modulate memory encoding, and this effect depends on interactions between the substantia nigra/ventral tegmental area complex (SN/VTA) and the hippocampus. It is unknown, however, whether these interactions influence offline neural activity in the human brain that is thought to promote memory consolidation. Here we used fMRI to test the effect of reward motivation on post-learning neural dynamics and subsequent memory for objects that were learned in high- and low-reward motivation contexts. We found that post-learning increases in resting-state functional connectivity between the SN/VTA and hippocampus predicted preferential retention of objects that were learned in high-reward contexts. In addition, multivariate pattern classification revealed that hippocampal representations of high-reward contexts were preferentially reactivated during post-learning rest, and the number of hippocampal reactivations was predictive of preferential retention of items learned in high-reward contexts. These findings indicate that reward motivation alters offline post-learning dynamics between the SN/VTA and hippocampus, providing novel evidence for a potential mechanism by which reward could influence memory consolidation.

“Post-learning Hippocampal Dynamics Promote Preferential Retention of Rewarding Events” by Matthias J. Gruber, Maureen Ritchey, Shao-Fang Wang, Manoj K. Doss, and Charan Ranganath in Neuron. Published online February 11 2016 doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2016.01.017

Feel free to share this Neuroscience News.
Join our Newsletter
I agree to have my personal information transferred to AWeber for Neuroscience Newsletter ( more information )
Sign up to receive our recent neuroscience headlines and summaries sent to your email once a day, totally free.
We hate spam and only use your email to contact you about newsletters. You can cancel your subscription any time.