Summary: Hikikomori, the condition of extreme social isolation, is more ubiquitous than previously believed. Researchers say modern tools to help improve interpersonal communication may have the opposite effect.
Source: Oregon Health and Science University
Experts in the Japanese phenomena of hikikomori say the condition of extreme social isolation is more widespread than previously acknowledged, and it deserves a clear and consistent definition to improve treatment across the globe.
In an article published in the February issue of the journal World Psychiatry, experts cite a lack of broad clinical understanding of the condition.
Although hikikomori is typically associated with young adults in Japan, the researchers say many of the same criteria of extended social isolation apply to people around the world, including among older adults and stay-at-home parents. A simplified and clear definition will improve the recognition and subsequent treatment for people who suffer from the condition, the authors write.
The article highlights four key aspects of the newly proposed definition of hikikomori:
* Confined at home: The proposed definition clarifies the frequency of time spent outside the home, while still meeting the definition of “marked social isolation.”
* Avoiding people: Some people choose to avoid social situations and interaction not because they’re anxious but because it meets their comfort level. The newly suggested definition therefore removes the avoidance of social situations as a criteria.
* Better defining distress: Many people diagnosed with hikikomori report that they feel content in their social withdrawal. However, as the duration of social withdrawal gets longer, their distress and feelings of loneliness increases.
* Other disorders: Co-occurring mental health conditions such as depression should not exclude patients from also being assessed for and diagnosed with hikikomori. “In our view, the frequency of co-occurring conditions increases the importance of addressing social withdrawal as a health issue,” they write.
Senior author Alan Teo, M.D., associate professor of psychiatry in Oregon Health & Science University School of Medicine and a researcher and psychiatrist in the VA Portland Health Care System, said the medical profession hasn’t traditionally recognized social isolation as a health issue.
“There is a cultural issue within the house of medicine whereby we don’t pay attention to it and don’t think it is in our lane to deal with,” he said. “These are shared problems, whether it’s an 80-year-old Portlander who’s a meals-on-wheels recipient living by herself or an 18-year-old with hikikomori in Japan.”
Ironically, modern tools to improve communication may be having the opposite effect.
“With advances in digital and communications technologies that provide alternatives to in-person social interaction, hikikomori may become an increasingly relevant concern,” the authors write.
Spending time online can be damaging when it substitutes for interacting with people face to face, Teo said. Those person-to-person social relationships are a critical aspect of mental health.
“Your social life is critical to your quality of life – yet in health care, we often forget to think about that,” Teo said.
“A person’s day-to-day social life is really what brings them meaning and value.”
In addition to Teo, the other authors included Takahiro A. Kato, M.D., Ph.D., and Shigenobu Kanba, M.D., Ph.D., of Kyushu University in Japan.
The recommendations published online today in World Psychiatry represent an outgrowth of earlier collaboration between the three authors, including a perspective published in the journal Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences in 2019.
Funding: Teo’s work is supported by a Career Development Award (CDA 14-428) from the U.S. Veterans Health Administration Health Service Research and Development and the HSR&D Center to Improve Veteran Involvement in Care. The views expressed in the paper are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position nor policy of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs of the U.S. government.
Defining pathological social withdrawal: proposed diagnostic criteria for hikikomori
In the late 1990s, a severe and prolonged form of social withdrawal typically observed among adolescents and youth transitioning to adulthood entered the collective national consciousness in Japan. Called “hikikomori” , it has shifted in recent years from being viewed as a typical Japanese problem to an issue that may have global health implications. This shift has been driven by increasing evidence of hikikomori in epidemiologic studies, clinical case series and media reports from around the world.