Scientists Use Robots to Reveal How Predatory Fish Cope With Unpredictable Prey

Summary: Findings challenge the long-standing view that behaving unpredictably helps animals survive when they encounter predators.

Source: University of Bristol

Scientists at the University of Bristol have demonstrated how predators overcome their preys’ erratic behavior by adapting their own during the hunt.

The study, published today in scientific journal PNAS, challenges the well-held theory that behaving unpredictably helps animals survive encounters with predators.

Instead of simply fleeing directly away from a predator, many prey species from across the animal kingdom choose to escape in a surprisingly wide range of directions. Scientists have long suspected that this unpredictability helps them evade capture by keeping predators guessing about the prey’s next move.

By studying how real predatory fish (blue acara cichlids) attack robotic prey, researchers from Bristol’s School of Biological Sciences were able to experimentally test this idea. Rather than confirming that unpredictable escape tactics are beneficial to prey, the new research suggests that predators can neutralize this strategy by flexibly adjusting their own behavior.

Like many real prey hiding from predators, the robotic prey started each experiment motionless, before eventually fleeing once the cichlid predator got too close. But unlike real prey, their escape direction could be programmed in advance.

This key design feature enabled the researchers to vary how predictable the prey’s escape direction was over a series of interactions with the predators.

Lead author Dr Andrew Szopa-Comley explained: “Using robotic prey allowed us to present individual predators with one of two prey escape strategies: ‘predictable’ prey which repeatedly escaped in the same direction from one interaction with the predator to the next, or ‘unpredictable’ prey which escaped in random directions.”

Predators facing predictable prey adjusted their speed of approach according to the prey’s escape direction, going faster when prey were heading directly away from them and more slowly if prey were fleeing sideways.

This adjustment occurred before the prey even started to escape, suggesting that the predators were able to anticipate the prey’s behaviour, based on their experience of previous interactions.

By contrast, predator individuals facing unpredictable prey did not adjust their approach speed to match the prey’s escape angle.

And yet surprisingly, over the length of a whole pursuit, predators faced with unpredictable prey performed just as well as those hunting predictable prey.

This shows fish interacting with the robot
Fish interacting with robot. Credit: Christos Ioannou

Despite being deprived of reliable information on the prey’s likely escape direction, predators faced with unpredictable prey were able to compensate by accelerating more in the later stages of the pursuit.

Senior author Dr Christos Ioannou, Associate Professor of Behavioural Ecology commented: “Our results suggest that the predators in our study were able to overcome the potential downsides of facing prey which behave unpredictably. From the prey’s point of view, this raises the question of whether unpredictable behaviour is as widely beneficial as was originally thought.”

These findings are potentially significant for the evolution of prey escape behaviour. They suggest that the behavioural characteristics of the predator, including its capacity to counteradapt, may be crucial in determining whether being unpredictable is beneficial to prey.

Dr Szopa-Comley, added: “One of the key messages from our research is that predators are capable of dynamically adjusting their behaviour in a way that can have dramatic consequences for the success of prey survival strategies.”

About this robotics and behavioral neuroscience research news

Author: Laura Thomas
Source: University of Bristol
Contact: Laura Thomas – University of Bristol
Image: The image is credited to Christos Ioannou

Original Research: Open access.
Responsive robotic prey reveal how predators adapt to predictability in escape tactics” by Christos Ioannou et al. PNAS


Responsive robotic prey reveal how predators adapt to predictability in escape tactics

To increase their chances of survival, prey often behave unpredictably when escaping from predators. However, the response of predators to, and hence the effectiveness of, such tactics is unknown.

We programmed interactive prey to flee from an approaching fish predator (the blue acara, Andinoacara pulcher) using real-time computer vision and two-wheeled robots that controlled the prey’s movements via magnets. This allowed us to manipulate the prey’s initial escape direction and how predictable it was between successive trials with the same individual predator.

When repeatedly exposed to predictable prey, the predators adjusted their behavior before the prey even began to escape: prey programmed to escape directly away were approached more rapidly than prey escaping at an acute angle. These faster approach speeds compensated for a longer time needed to capture such prey during the subsequent pursuit phase.

By contrast, when attacking unpredictable prey, the predators adopted intermediate approach speeds and were not sensitive to the prey’s escape angle but instead showed greater acceleration during the pursuit.

Collectively, these behavioral responses resulted in the prey’s predictability having no net effect on the time taken to capture prey, suggesting that unpredictable escape behavior may be advantageous to prey in fewer circumstances than originally thought.

Rather than minimizing capture times, the predators in our study appear to instead adjust their behavior to maintain an adequate level of performance during prey capture.

Join our Newsletter
I agree to have my personal information transferred to AWeber for Neuroscience Newsletter ( more information )
Sign up to receive our recent neuroscience headlines and summaries sent to your email once a day, totally free.
We hate spam and only use your email to contact you about newsletters. You can cancel your subscription any time.