Neuroscience News logo for mobile.
      Neuroscience News Logo

      Sacrificing One Life to Save Others: Psychopaths’ Force for ‘Greater Good’

      FeaturedOpen Neuroscience ArticlesPsychology
      ·October 25, 2017

      Summary: The force by which a person embarks upon a utilitarian act may be predicted by psychopathic traits, a new study reports.

      Source: University of Plymouth.

      New research shows people would sacrifice one life to save others – and people with psychopathic traits would carry out the actions with greater force.

      New research shows that people would sacrifice one person to save a larger group of people – and in addition, the force with which they carry out these actions could be predicted by psychopathic traits.

      The study, led by the University of Plymouth, compared what people ‘said’ they would do with what they actually ‘did’ by comparing a questionnaire with actions in immersive moral dilemmas created using virtual-haptic technologies (i.e. using a robotic device which measures force, resistance, and speed, whilst simulating the action of harming a human).

      In several dilemmas, participants had to decide whether to sacrifice a person by performing a harmful action against them, in order to save a larger group of people.

      While all individuals were more likely to sacrifice others in these immersive environments than in questionnaire-based assessments, people with strong psychopathic traits were more likely to generate these harmful actions with greater physical power.

      Psychopathy is generally characterised by antisocial behaviour and impaired empathy. As such, it is thought that individuals with strong psychopathic traits find it less emotionally challenging to sanction utilitarian actions.

      In the present research, this resilience to performing actively harmful acts appears to enable these individuals to act for the ‘greater good’ (i.e. to save the many). This result therefore indicates that, in certain circumstances, psychopathic traits could be considered beneficial, since they can lead to a more vigorous response.

      This study is a result of an interdisciplinary collaboration between Dr Kathryn Francis, Dr Sylvia Terbeck, Raluca Briazu, Dr Michaela Gummerum, and Dr Giorgio Ganis in the University’s School of Psychology, Agi Haines, a designer based in the University’s Transtechnology research group, and Dr Ian Howard of the Centre for Robotics and Neural Systems.

      faceless dummies
      In the present research, this resilience to performing actively harmful acts appears to enable these individuals to act for the ‘greater good’ (i.e. to save the many). This result therefore indicates that, in certain circumstances, psychopathic traits could be considered beneficial, since they can lead to a more vigorous response. NeuroscienceNews.com image is in the public domain.

      Dr Francis, now a Postdoctoral Research Fellow in Philosophy and Psychology at the University of Reading, said:

      “This research highlights our proneness to moral inconsistency; what we say and what we do can be very different. For the first time, we demonstrate how personality traits can influence the physical power of our moral actions. Importantly, the multidisciplinary approaches that we have used here, combining virtual reality, robotics, and interactive sculpture, places further emphasis on the need to unite the sciences and the arts when investigating complex phenomena such as morality.”

      Dr Sylvia Terbeck, Lecturer in Social Psychology and study co-author, added:

      “This study opens up the possibility to assess psychopathy using novel virtual reality technology – which is vital to better understand how and why people with these behavioural traits act in certain ways.”

      Dr Ian Howard, Associate Professor in the Centre for Robotics and Neural Systems, said:

      “This work shows how techniques developed to study human movement can play a value role in psychological assessment and thereby lead to new insights into human social behaviour.”

      About this neuroscience research article

      Funding: The full study, which was supported by CogNovo.

      Source: Martin Herrema – University of Plymouth
      Publisher: Organized by NeuroscienceNews.com.
      Image Source: NeuroscienceNews.com image is in the public domain.
      Original Research: Full open access research for “Simulating Moral Actions: An Investigation of Personal Force in Virtual Moral Dilemmas” by K. B. Francis, S. Terbeck, R. A. Briazu, A. Haines, M. Gummerum, G. Ganis & I. S. Howard in Scientific Reports. Published online October 24 2017 doi:10.1038/s41598-017-13909-9

      Cite This NeuroscienceNews.com Article

      [cbtabs][cbtab title=”MLA”]University of Plymouth “Sacrificing One Life to Save Others: Psychopaths’ Force for ‘Greater Good’.” NeuroscienceNews. NeuroscienceNews, 25 October 2017.
      <https://neurosciencenews.com/psychopath-utilitarianism-force-7810/>.[/cbtab][cbtab title=”APA”]University of Plymouth (2017, October 25). Sacrificing One Life to Save Others: Psychopaths’ Force for ‘Greater Good’. NeuroscienceNews. Retrieved October 25, 2017 from https://neurosciencenews.com/psychopath-utilitarianism-force-7810/[/cbtab][cbtab title=”Chicago”]University of Plymouth “Sacrificing One Life to Save Others: Psychopaths’ Force for ‘Greater Good’.” https://neurosciencenews.com/psychopath-utilitarianism-force-7810/ (accessed October 25, 2017).[/cbtab][/cbtabs]


      Abstract

      Simulating Moral Actions: An Investigation of Personal Force in Virtual Moral Dilemmas

      Advances in Virtual Reality (VR) technologies allow the investigation of simulated moral actions in visually immersive environments. Using a robotic manipulandum and an interactive sculpture, we now also incorporate realistic haptic feedback into virtual moral simulations. In two experiments, we found that participants responded with greater utilitarian actions in virtual and haptic environments when compared to traditional questionnaire assessments of moral judgments. In experiment one, when incorporating a robotic manipulandum, we found that the physical power of simulated utilitarian responses (calculated as the product of force and speed) was predicted by individual levels of psychopathy. In experiment two, which integrated an interactive and life-like sculpture of a human into a VR simulation, greater utilitarian actions continued to be observed. Together, these results support a disparity between simulated moral action and moral judgment. Overall this research combines state-of-the-art virtual reality, robotic movement simulations, and realistic human sculptures, to enhance moral paradigms that are often contextually impoverished. As such, this combination provides a better assessment of simulated moral action, and illustrates the embodied nature of morally-relevant actions.

      “Simulating Moral Actions: An Investigation of Personal Force in Virtual Moral Dilemmas” by K. B. Francis, S. Terbeck, R. A. Briazu, A. Haines, M. Gummerum, G. Ganis & I. S. Howard in Scientific Reports. Published online October 24 2017 doi:10.1038/s41598-017-13909-9

      Feel free to share this Neuroscience News.
      Join our Newsletter
      Thank you for subscribing.
      Something went wrong.
      I agree to have my personal information transferred to AWeber for Neuroscience Newsletter ( more information )
      Sign up to receive our recent neuroscience headlines and summaries sent to your email once a day, totally free.
      We hate spam and only use your email to contact you about newsletters. You can cancel your subscription any time.
      Tags
      forcehaptic feedbackNeuroboticsOpen Accessopen sciencephilosophyPsychologypsychopathpsychopathic traitspsychopathyRoboticstrolley problemUniversity of Plymouthutilitarianismvirtual haptic technoogyvirtual reality
      ShareTweetShareShareSubmitEmail
      Neuroscience News
      Neuroscience News posts science research news from labs, universities, hospitals and news departments around the world. Science articles cover neuroscience, psychology, AI, robotics, neurology, brain cancer, mental health, machine learning, autism, Parkinson's, Alzheimer's, brain research, depression and other sciences.
      Related
      This shows a teen looking at a phone.

      TikTok ADHD Misinformation Can Mislead Young Minds

      This shows a group of people.

      Universally Cool: Personality Traits That Cross Cultural Lines

      This shows a person sleeping and cheese.

      Eating Dairy May Trigger Nightmares

      Neuroscience News Footer Logo
      • Facebook
      • X
      • Instagram
      • YouTube
      • Linkedin

      Neuroscience News Sitemap
      Neuroscience Graduate and Undergraduate Programs
      Free Neuroscience MOOCs
      About
      Contact Us
      Privacy Policy
      Submit Neuroscience News
      Subscribe for Emails

      Neuroscience Research
      Psychology News
      Brain Cancer Research
      Alzheimer’s Disease
      Parkinson’s News
      Autism / ASD News
      Neurotechnology News
      Artificial Intelligence News
      Robotics News

      Search Neuroscience News

      Neuroscience News is an online science magazine offering free to read research articles about neuroscience, neurology, psychology, artificial intelligence, neurotechnology, robotics, deep learning, neurosurgery, mental health and more.

      Neuroscience News
      • Neuroscience
        • Featured
        • Neuroscience Videos
        • Neuro Web Stories
        • Open Access Neuroscience
        • Electrophysiology
        • Genetics
        • Neuroscience Programs
      • Neurology
        • Alzheimer’s Disease
        • Brain Research
        • Brain Cancer
        • Autism
        • Epilepsy
        • Traumatic Brain Injuries
        • Parkinson’s Disease
      • Psychology
        • Schizophrenia
        • Depression
        • Bipolar Disorder
        • Mental Health
      • AI
        • Neural Networks
        • Deep Learning
        • Machine Learning
      • Robotics
      • Neurotech
        • Brain Computer Interfaces
        • Neuroprosthetics
      • About
        • Neuroscience Newsletters
        • Submit Neuroscience News
        • Privacy Policy
        • Neuroscience News Sitemap
        • Contact Neuroscience News
        • Advertise on Neuroscience News
      Neuroscience News Small Logo
      • Neuroscience
        • Featured
        • Neuroscience Videos
        • Neuro Web Stories
        • Open Access Neuroscience
        • Electrophysiology
        • Genetics
        • Neuroscience Programs
      • Neurology
        • Alzheimer’s Disease
        • Brain Research
        • Brain Cancer
        • Autism
        • Epilepsy
        • Traumatic Brain Injuries
        • Parkinson’s Disease
      • Psychology
        • Schizophrenia
        • Depression
        • Bipolar Disorder
        • Mental Health
      • AI
        • Neural Networks
        • Deep Learning
        • Machine Learning
      • Robotics
      • Neurotech
        • Brain Computer Interfaces
        • Neuroprosthetics
      • About
        • Neuroscience Newsletters
        • Submit Neuroscience News
        • Privacy Policy
        • Neuroscience News Sitemap
        • Contact Neuroscience News
        • Advertise on Neuroscience News

      Categories

      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Auditory Neuroscience
      • Autism
      • Brain Cancer
      • Deep Learning
      • Electrophysiology
      • Events
      • Featured
      • Featured Articles
      • Genetics
      • Machine Learning
      • Most Popular
      • Neuroethics
      • Neurology
      • Neuroscience
      • Neuroscience Abstracts
      • Neuroscience Book Reviews
      • Neuroscience Business
      • Neuroscience Intros
      • Neuroscience News
      • Neuroscience News.com
      • Neuroscience Opinions
      • Neuroscience Videos
      • Neurotech
      • Open Neuroscience Articles
      • Pain
      • Psychology
      • Robotics
      • Sponsored Neuroscience News
      • Visual Neuroscience
      Neuroscience News LogoNeuroscience News
      This shows an ear.

      Gene Therapy Restores Hearing in Those with Deafness

      This shows a brain.

      Forever Chemicals May Disrupt Brain Development

      This shows kids playing games.

      Kids Outsmart AI in Puzzle Game That Builds Critical Thinking

      This shows a neuron.

      Drug-Coated Neural Implants Reduce Immune Rejection

      Start typing to see results or hit ESC to close
      Neuroscience neurobiology brain research Psychology Neurology
      See all results

      Subscribe

      Neuroscience News Daily Emails
      Go to Appearance > Customize > Subscribe Pop-up to set this up.