Individual Differences in the Brain

Summary: Distinct personality traits emerge and manifest via both behavior and neural activity.

Source: Max Planck Institute

Personality varies widely. There are bold and reserved individuals, who behave very differently when faced with the same environmental stimulus. What is true for humans also applies to fish: their behavior shows a range of individual differences. By selectively breeding zebrafish, scientists from the Max Planck Institute of Neurobiology were able to show that distinct personality traits rapidly emerge and manifest not only in the behavior, but also through far-reaching changes in the brain.

Young zebrafish are just five millimeters long and almost transparent. Nevertheless, the tiny fish display a spectrum of behavior in response to external stimuli. While some animals flee in panic at a loud sound, other fish remain calm. If the sound is repeated, fish in one group learn to ignore it quickly, while others never really get used to it. Between these two extremes – relaxed or skittish – there is a whole range of behavioral expressions.

Carlos Pantoja and colleagues in Herwig Baier’s team were now able to show that selection for a specific behavioral trait can also change the fishes’ brain activity surprisingly quickly. The researchers mated animals only within the extremely relaxed and the extremely skittish groups. After just two generations, the brains of the fry selected for skittishness differed significantly from the brains of the calm offspring.

In the transparent fish larvae, the scientists were able to observe which brain regions were activated by the loud sound. The offspring of the two behavioral extremes showed clear differences in neuronal activity in a part of the hypothalamus and in the so-called dorsal raphe nucleus. A noticeable difference between these two brain regions is that the plastic part of the hypothalamus contains neurons that secrete dopamine, while the raphe nucleus mainly produces serotonin. Dopamine and serotonin are two prominent neuromodulators that have also been associated with personality differences and even psychiatric conditions in humans.

“The ratio of cell activity in these two brain regions could regulate the sensitivity of an individual fish’s reaction to the sound and how quickly it gets used to it,” explains Carlos Pantoja. “However, this is certainly only one component, as there are also differences in a whole range of other brain areas.”

This shows zebrafish
Zebrafish react with individual differences to loud sounds. A selection towards pronounced behavioral responses shows, within a few generations, also in differences in brain activity. Image is credited to MPI of Neurobiology / Kuhl.

Interestingly, the offspring of the two fish groups not only showed the expected differences in their startle response. While in the larval stage, the more relaxed fish fry was also significantly less spontaneously active. As adults, these fish then adapted much slower to a new environment than adult jumpy fish. “At first glance, this sounds paradoxical. But it could be that the early tendency to fearful overreactions tends to dampen the later stress response,” says Pantoja. Similar long-term effects of early stress processing have been reported in mammals.

In both groups of fish, the dopamine-releasing part of the hypothalamus was activated during the startle reaction. However, while this region was only switched on by the sound in the relaxed fish, it was permanently active in the skittish fish. After a mere two generations of behavioral selection, these animals already seemed to be constantly prepared to escape.

“The pace at which personality traits can be shifted and fixed in evolution is remarkable,” reflects Herwig Baier. “The process might be similarly rapid in populations of Homo sapiens.” The zebrafish could perhaps reveal some of the involved brain structures and the genetic basis of this plasticity.

About this individual differences research article

Max Planck Institute
Press Office – Max Planck Institute
Image Source:
The image is credited to MPI of Neurobiology / Kuhl.

Original Research: Open access
“Rapid effects of selection on brain-wide activity and behavior” by Carlos Pantoja, Johannes Larsch, Eva Laurell, Greg Marquart, Michael Kunst & Herwig Baier. Current Biology.


Rapid effects of selection on brain-wide activity and behavior

• ASR habituation-selected zebrafish larvae differ in whole-brain activity patterns
• Low habituation selection leads to increased activity in ASR circuits at baseline
• High habituation selection increases activity in HC dopamine neurons
• Selected animals differ in swim activity as larvae and stress responses as adults

Interindividual variation in behavior and brain activity is universal and provides substrates for natural selection. Selective pressures shift the expression of behavioral traits at the population level, but the accompanying changes of the underlying neural circuitry have rarely been identified. Selection likely acts through the genetic and/or epigenetic underpinnings of neural activity controlling the selected behavior. Endocrine and neuromodulatory systems participate in behavioral diversity and could provide the substrate for evolutionary modifications. Here, we examined brain-wide patterns of activity in larval zebrafish selectively bred over two generations for extreme differences in habituation of the acoustic startle response (ASR). The ASR is an evolutionarily conserved defensive behavior induced by strong acoustic/vibrational stimuli. ASR habituation shows great individual variability that is stable over days and heritable. Selection for high ASR habituation leads to stronger sound-evoked activation of ASR-processing brain areas. In contrast, animals selected for low habituation displayed stronger spontaneous activity in ASR-processing centers. Ablation of dopaminergic tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) neurons decreased ASR sensitivity. Independently selected ASR habituation lineages link the effect of behavioral selection to dopaminergic caudal hypothalamus (HC) neurons. High ASR habituation co-segregated with decreased spontaneous swimming phenotypes, but visual startle responses were unaffected. Furthermore, high- and low-habituation larvae differed in stress responses as adults. Thus, selective pressure over a couple of generations on ASR habituation behavior is able to induce substantial differences in brain activity, carrying along additional behaviors as piggyback traits that might further affect fitness in the wild.

Join our Newsletter
I agree to have my personal information transferred to AWeber for Neuroscience Newsletter ( more information )
Sign up to receive our recent neuroscience headlines and summaries sent to your email once a day, totally free.
We hate spam and only use your email to contact you about newsletters. You can cancel your subscription any time.