Tuesday May 22nd 2012
Neuroscience News on Google Plus Neuroscience News On Twitter Neuroscience News on Facebook

Protective Brain Hypothesis Confirmed – Larger Brains Live Longer

Large brains have been correlated with longevity in some animals. Despite many problems created by large brains such as energy consumption and birthing difficulties, species with large brains have been shown to live longer than those with smaller brains. Information from this brain research will aid study in the evolution of the brain.

The protective brain hypothesis is confirmed

“In the past, it was thought that one of the selective advantages of having a large brain is that it facilitates the development of new behaviour to respond to the ecological challenges that the individual has not experienced before, such as a sudden reduction in food or the appearance of a new predator “, César González-Lagos, main author of the study and researcher at the Centre of Ecological Research and Forestry Applications (CREAF) associated with the Autonomous University of Barcelona, highlights to SINC.

The results, which are published in the Journal of Evolutionary Biology, reveal that “species which have developed large brains live for longer than those with small brains, as the protective brain theory suggests, and therefore, can reproduce more times”, the researcher stresses.

If the animal is protected by a large brain, this results in greater survival and a longer life. “However until recently there has been little evidence and there had been no agreement on whether species with larger brains live longer”, the scientist points out.

According to this hypothesis, the brain would adopt a “protective” role which would help to reduce mortality and lengthen the reproductive live of the individuals, thereby compensating the energetic and development costs associated with a large brain.

The evidence is correlative, not cause-effect

The team analysed 493 species of mammals from different regions of the planet. According to the authors, the evidence resulting from the study is “correlative”, in other words they do not “necessarily” indicate cause-effect, but the analysis indicates that the link between a large brain and longevity is not only due to the fact that species with large brains are greater in size and develop more slowly, they also live in specific regions or share the same evolutionary ancestors.

“As extension of life duration is central to many hypotheses on the advantages of developing large brains, these results offer a solid base which can be used to continue building a general theory on the evolution of the brain”, concludes the scientist.

The first observations of Darwin

Throughout their evolutionary history some mammals, such as primates, cetaceans and elephants, have developed much larger brains than would be expected for their body size. But a large brain involves energetic costs and development time.

In El descendiente del Hombre (The descendent of Man) (1871), the British naturalist Charles Darwin, always attracted by this question, thought that a large brain, such as that of humans, improved the mental capacity of individuals, because natural selection favours the appearance of large brains.

Darwin believed that with a large brain mental capacity is improved. But, what selective advantage does it offer? The controversy on the advantages of having a larger brain continues.
Bibliographical reference: Gonzalez-Lagos, C.; Sol, D.; Reader, S.M. “Large-brained mammals live longer” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 23(5): 1064-1074, May 2010. doi:10.1111/j.1420-9101.2010.01976.x

Source:  FECYT – Spanish Foundation for Science and Technology

Animals with larger brains live longer.
Species with larger brains live longer on average than their smaller brained counterparts. Image: adapted from Wikipedia.org

Related Neuroscience Articles

20 Comments for “Protective Brain Hypothesis Confirmed – Larger Brains Live Longer”


Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Related Articles

Stem Cell Research Could Benefit Fragile X Patients
Stem Cell Research Could Benefit Fragile X Patients

Stem Cell Research Paves way for Progress on Dealing with Fragile X Retardation Researchers at the Hebrew University of [Read More]

Von Economo Neurons Discovered In Macaque Monkey Insular Cortex
Von Economo Neurons Discovered In Macaque Monkey Insular Cortex

Rare Neurons Discovered in Monkey Brains Max Planck scientists discover brain cells in monkeys that may be linked to [Read More]

Oxytocin Could Help Improve Processing Social Information in Children With Autism
Oxytocin Could Help Improve Processing Social Information in Children With Autism

Oxytocin Improves Brain Function in Children with Autism Preliminary results from an ongoing, large-scale study by Yale [Read More]

Paralyzed Individuals Use Thought Controlled Robotic Arm to Reach and Grasp
Paralyzed Individuals Use Thought Controlled Robotic Arm to Reach and Grasp

NIH-funded study shows progress in brain-computer interface technology. In an ongoing clinical trial, a paralyzed woman [Read More]

Sugar Makes You Stupid: Study Shows High Fructose Diet Sabotages Learning and Memory
Sugar Makes You Stupid: Study Shows High Fructose Diet Sabotages Learning and Memory

This is your brain on sugar: UCLA study shows high-fructose diet sabotages learning, memory. Attention, college [Read More]

Neuroscience Jobs

  1. Submit an article, personal story, question, blog post or a news tip from this area. Submissions are welcome from everyone. Scientists, patients, students, doctors, neuroscience geeks, researchers, bloggers, etc. are all welcome to share their opinions about neuroscience. As long as it pertains to neuroscience related information, and isn't overly offensive to nearly everyone that could read it, we will post it. Credit will be given to the submitter unless asked not to in the text area. We'll contact you in the email provided to ask, or answer any questions. We look forward to your Neuroscience News contribution.