Summary: A new study finds that male house mice adopt flexible mating strategies tied to their personality traits and environment. Some males consistently defend territories, while others roam for mates, adjusting based on body condition, rivals, and social surroundings.
While territorial males reproduce more often, roamers still succeed, especially under high competition, and even show larger testes, hinting at greater sperm investment. These findings reveal how behavior, physiology, and survival strategies dynamically evolve in real time, offering fresh insight into adaptability in the animal kingdom.
Key Facts:
- Flexible Strategies: Male house mice shift between territorial defense and roaming based on personality, condition, and environment.
- Tradeoffs in Reproduction: Territorial males reproduce more but face higher risks, while roamers succeed under high competition.
- Physiological Investment: Roaming males have larger testes, likely enhancing reproductive success during fleeting mating opportunities.
Source; Max Planck Institute
In a comprehensive study at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology, led by Fragkiskos Darmis, with Anja Guenther and Alexandros Vezyrakis, researchers tracked 244 wild-derived male house mice—yes, the kind you’d find in barns or basements—over their entire lives, up to eleven months, in real-world-style enclosures.
They discovered that while these mating strategies are flexible, they’re also tied to consistent individual differences—what scientists call “personality traits.”
Some mice might just consistently roam and some might just defend nests.
Here’s the twist: these behaviours don’t need to be hardwired in DNA. Instead, they can emerge based on the male’s circumstances—what evolutionary biologists call “making the best of a bad job.”
It’s not that these males are born roamers or territorials—it’s that they’re adaptable. Their behaviour evolves in real-time, shaped by their body, their rivals, and their environment. When a male can’t win the territory game, roaming becomes a smart backup plan.
Who wins?
Territorial males tend to reproduce more often—but at a cost. Defending the nest areas where females gather can be stressful and risky, increasing the chance of injury and likely elevating stress levels.
Roamers, on the other hand, may reproduce less frequently, but they still manage to pass on their genes—especially when competition is high. In the end, both strategies can lead to similar lifetime success.
The researchers also found that roaming males have relatively larger testes, suggesting they invest more in sperm production—perhaps to improve their chances in brief encounters. It’s not just behavior that differs—physiology and energy investment do too.
The study shows that male house mice adopt different mating strategies based on their personality, body condition, and social environment. These strategies—defending a territory or roaming for mates—not only shape their chances of reproducing but also lead to different life paths. Some live longer, others take more risks.
The findings reveal how flexible and dynamic these behaviours are, and suggest that males might respond differently as environments change, offering new insight into how animals adapt and evolve.
About this evolutionary neuroscience research news
Author: Fragkiskos Darmis
Source: Max Planck Institute
Contact: Fragkiskos Darmis – Max Planck Institute
Image: The image is credited to Neuroscience News
Original Research: Open access.
“Male reproductive tactics in house mice: Consistent individual differences, intrinsic factors and density effects” by Fragkiskos Darmis et al. Journal of Animal Ecology
Abstract
Male reproductive tactics in house mice: Consistent individual differences, intrinsic factors and density effects
- Alternative reproductive tactics (ARTs) describe non-reversible or flexible alternative strategies that secure fertilization. For example, some male defend territories with females while others attempt sneaky matings. Often, ARTs are considered to be status-dependent and are explained by differences in mass or competitive ability. However, most studies on ARTs only approximate their fitness effect, ignore males that never reproduced and consider status (e.g. weight) as the sole mediator of ARTs.
- We used 244 male mice, Mus musculus domesticus, from semi-natural populations, to describe ARTs in Mus Musculus for the first time. We followed males throughout their life and categorized them as territorials or roamers over multiple monthly intervals, after validating our method of assigning tactics with detailed spatial data.
- We explored if tactic choice is repeatable, whether multiple social and/or intrinsic factors predict tactic choice and transitions between tactics, and tested for fitness and physiological differences between ARTs.
- Tactic choice was repeatable, but males switched flexibly between tactics. Tactic choice was associated with mass, age, the operational sex ratio and population size. Territorials had a higher probability of reproduction, but a lower gonadosomatic index.
- Our results reveal a personality component of ARTs, confirm equal mean fitness among tactics and suggest tactic choice as a multifaceted decision under various selective pressures.
