Combining information across multiple senses helps in choosing an appropriate action. While many examples exist of such synergistic effects, very few studies have identified the neural architecture underlying multisensory convergence. In particular, whether distinct sensory streams converge early, late or at multiple levels in the sensory processing hierarchy was an open question. Using behavioral testing, neuronal activation screens, and electron microscopy reconstructions of the nervous system of fruit fly larvae, scientists at Howard Hughes Medical Institute’s Janelia Research Campus have mapped the entire neural circuit involved in combining vibration and pain sensations used in triggering an escape behavior.
The researchers discovered that the two sensory streams converge at multiple layers of the sensory processing hierarchy. This multilevel convergence likely facilitates discrimination between different kinds of multisensory events. The results were reported online April 20, 2015 in Nature.
“Initially I would have thought this circuit would be simpler, but the complex network could really allow the animal to do a complex computation and react to very particular combinations of cues,” says Janelia group leader Marta Zlatic, a neurobiologist and one of the leaders of the research team.
The fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, exhibits an array of distinct escape behaviors, such as turning, digging, fast crawling and rolling – a response to threatening situations, including predator attacks that elicit both mechanosensory, or vibratory, and nociceptive, or painful, sensations.
While mechanosensory and nociceptive neurons had previously been identified, the interneurons onto which the two sensory streams converge, and the command neurons that actually initiate the rolling response, were not known. To map out this circuit, the research teams of Zlatic and Albert Cardona used a three-pronged approach that incorporated iterative rounds of behavioral testing, genetic screens to identify neurons involved in the rolling behavior, and the reconstruction of neural circuits from electron microscopy images of ultrathin sections of larval brain tissue.
First, to trigger rolling, the researchers used speaker-emitted vibrations and the activation of nociceptive neurons that simulated, respectively, the mechanosensory and nociceptive aspects of a predator attack. The effect of combining these two sensory cues was highly synergistic with combinations of cues triggering rolling with much greater probability than either cue alone.
Next, Tomoko Ohyama, the co-first author on the study, performed a screen of hundreds of transgenic mutants – each of which expresses in a distinct subset of neurons – created by group leaders Gerry Rubin, Jim Truman and Janelia’s Fly Light Project team. Ohyama identified neurons that when stimulated triggered rolling and appeared to innervate the early sensory processing centers in the nerve cord.
In parallel, in a series of electron microscopic images that spanned one segment of the nerve cord, Casey Schneider-Mizell and Cardona reconstructed all the interneurons directly downstream of the mechanosensory and nociceptive sensory axons, using a novel open source computer-assisted circuit mapping method developed by the Cardona lab. This revealed that two types (out of several hundred) first-order interneurons received multiple synaptic connections from both sensory modalities, whereas others mostly received inputs from a single modality. The roll-evoking neurons identified in Ohyama’s screen turned out to be the ones targeted by both the mechanosensory and nociceptive axons. Physiological studies confirmed these first-order interneurons integrate information from the two modalities, responding more to the combination of cues than to either cue alone.
Stimulating first-order mechanosensory interneurons in combination with the identified first-order multisensory interneurons led to an increased likelihood of rolling, indicating that their outputs were combined by interneurons in one or more higher processing layers. The transgenic screen also identified command neurons – dubbed “Goro” for the Japanese word for rolling – that were activated by stimulating the first-order multisensory interneurons and ultimately triggered the rolling behavior.
Finally, Schneider-Mizell mapped out the pathways between the first-order interneurons and the Goro command neurons from a second series of more than 5,000 electron microscopic sections of an entire larval nervous system collected by co-author Rick Fetter and Janelia’s Fly EM Project and registered by Cardona.
The circuit reconstruction revealed a complex multilevel, multimodal feedforward convergence architecture as well as multiple local and higher-order feedback motifs. Both nerve cord and brain pathways to Goro were present with multiple layers of interneurons in each pathway. Distinct types of second-order interneurons combine information from multisensory and unisensory first-order interneurons across multiple segments and ascend to the brain. The second-order interneurons, which received distinct combinations of first-order interneuron inputs – and therefore distinct combinations of mechanosensory and nociceptive inputs – re-converged again on third-order interneurons in the brain. These third-order interneurons synapse onto neurons that project descending inputs to the command neurons.
In a separate pathway, multisensory and mechanosensory first-order interneurons were connected to command neurons through a set of two interneurons in the nerve cord, bypassing the brain altogether. This pathway was sufficient to activate the command neurons even when the brain was removed. However, the brain pathway likely integrates information across all body segments and modulates command neuron activity based on body-wide sensory information.
“It was pretty surprising that sensory modalities would merge again and again at so many different levels,” says Zlatic. “But in a way it makes sense because that enables the network to tune itself to respond to particular combination of two cues. For example, to a particular combination of noxious and mechanical cues presented by predators. The weights in this network could be tuned either through experience or through evolution — a fascinating question for the future.”
Zlatic added that the multilevel, multisensory convergence architecture her team observed in the Drosophila larvae may be a general feature in multisensory circuits, enabling complex responses tunable to specific ecological needs. This multisensory circuit in a genetically tractable model system provides a basis for detailed investigation of structural circuit motifs that implement multisensory computations.
The Cardona lab has made the electron microscopic volume of the entire larval nervous system available for studying other circuits in the Drosophila larval nervous system. “We’ve invited the entire community and said, ‘Anyone interested in specific aspects of the nervous system can come and join the Cardona lab in the tracing efforts,’” Zlatic says. “If many people reconstruct different circuits of interest, we will soon complete a connectome of an insect nervous system and the whole effort will be synergistic.”
Source: Marta Zlatic, PhD – HHMI
Image Credit: The image is credited to Albert Cardona, Janelia Research Campus
Video Source: The video is available at the HHMI news center
Original Research: Abstract for “A multilevel multimodal circuit enhances action selection in Drosophila” by Tomoko Ohyama, Casey M. Schneider-Mizell, Richard D. Fetter, Javier Valdes Aleman, Romain Franconville, Marta Rivera-Alba, Brett D. Mensh, Kristin M. Branson, Julie H. Simpson, James W. Truman, Albert Cardona and Marta Zlatic in Nature. Published online April 20 2015 doi:10.1038/nature14297
Abstract
A multilevel multimodal circuit enhances action selection in Drosophila
Natural events present multiple types of sensory cues, each detected by a specialized sensory modality. Combining information from several modalities is essential for the selection of appropriate actions. Key to understanding multimodal computations is determining the structural patterns of multimodal convergence and how these patterns contribute to behaviour. Modalities could converge early, late or at multiple levels in the sensory processing hierarchy. Here we show that combining mechanosensory and nociceptive cues synergistically enhances the selection of the fastest mode of escape locomotion in Drosophila larvae. In an electron microscopy volume that spans the entire insect nervous system, we reconstructed the multisensory circuit supporting the synergy, spanning multiple levels of the sensory processing hierarchy. The wiring diagram revealed a complex multilevel multimodal convergence architecture. Using behavioural and physiological studies, we identified functionally connected circuit nodes that trigger the fastest locomotor mode, and others that facilitate it, and we provide evidence that multiple levels of multimodal integration contribute to escape mode selection. We propose that the multilevel multimodal convergence architecture may be a general feature of multisensory circuits enabling complex input–output functions and selective tuning to ecologically relevant combinations of cues.
“A multilevel multimodal circuit enhances action selection in Drosophila” by Tomoko Ohyama, Casey M. Schneider-Mizell, Richard D. Fetter, Javier Valdes Aleman, Romain Franconville, Marta Rivera-Alba, Brett D. Mensh, Kristin M. Branson, Julie H. Simpson, James W. Truman, Albert Cardona and Marta Zlatic in Nature. Published online April 20 2015 doi:10.1038/nature14297
