Summary: Researchers report half of suicidal teens in a hospital sample say the controversial TV show contributed to their suicidal symptoms.
Source: University of Michigan.
A significant proportion of suicidal teens treated in a psychiatric emergency department said that watching the Netflix series 13 Reasons Why had increased their suicide risk, a University of Michigan study finds.
The hit drama, widely popular among teens, has generated controversy for its depiction of suicide. Its story centers around a 17-year-old student, who, before her death, recorded cassettes that detail 13 reasons why she took her own life.
The show has raised concerns among mental health experts about its potentially negative impact on vulnerable youths.
Which is why Michigan Medicine researchers asked suicidal adolescents whether the show had contributed to suicide-related symptoms.
The findings, published in the journal Psychiatric Services, add to the body of literature about how at-risk teens may be reacting to the program.
“This show has been a real phenomenon, especially among teenagers,” says lead author Victor Hong, M.D., medical director of psychiatric emergency services at Michigan Medicine. “Its depiction of teen suicide has raised great concern among parents, health providers and educators.”
Of the 87 youths who participated in the survey between 2017 and 2018, half had watched at least one episode of the show, mostly teens ages 13 to 17. Among the 43 who had watched it, about half (21) said it heightened their suicide risk.
“Our study doesn’t confirm that the show is increasing suicide risk, but it confirms that we should definitely be concerned about its impact on impressionable and vulnerable youth,” says Hong.
“Few believe this type of media exposure will take kids who are not depressed and make them suicidal. The concern is about how this may negatively impact youth who are already teetering on the edge.”
Parental viewership absent
The idea for the study stemmed from anecdotal narratives shared among colleagues at different children’s hospitals, says Hong, noting that providers were hearing more teens being treated for suicidal symptoms talk about 13 Reasons Why.
The study also found that 84 percent of surveyed youth who had seen the show viewed it alone and were more likely to discuss their reactions with peers (81 percent) than with a parent (35 percent).
A second season of 13 Reasons Why, which debuted in May, opens with a disclaimer urging young viewers to watch the show with a trusted adult — and the importance of seeking help.
Still, very few parents in the U-M sample had watched the series themselves; some were unaware that their child had watched it.
The findings clash with a previous Netflix-commissioned report that found 71 percent of youths in a U.S. community sample talked to a parent about the series.
Hong says this possibly indicates some differences in the ability or desire of youths at high risk of suicide to have such discussions with their parents.
“The data from our sample of teens demonstrated that kids who were at high risk of suicide did not reach out to adults,” he adds. “They mostly watched the show alone or talked to friends, but they weren’t talking to parents, teachers or school counselors.
“Youths who are in greatest need of adult support may be less likely to seek it out.”
Diligence, conversation crucial
Of the teen viewers who said they believed the series increased their suicide risk, the majority strongly identified with the lead female character, Hannah Baker.
“The main character is easy to identify with,” Hong says. “She’s a teen girl who has suffered from sexual assault, bullying and anxiety — which, unfortunately, impact too many of our youth today.”
Researchers developed a 44-item questionnaire to assess several aspects of youths’ interactions with 13 Reasons Why, using caution to avoid advertising the series to those who were not already aware of it. Teens unfamiliar with the show weren’t asked additional questions.
Authors say further research is needed to accurately gauge how media content that focuses on youth suicide can influence the mental health and suicide risk of its viewers.
But in the meantime, there are plenty of red flags for parents to watch for.
“Our findings support the need for tailored prevention programming for vulnerable youths and education and training for their parents,” says study senior author Cheryl King, Ph.D., a child and adolescent psychologist at U-M’s C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital.
“Parents whose kids may be vulnerable or at a high risk for suicide should be even more diligent about what their kids watch and if they are being exposed to content that could trigger them,” she adds.
“They also shouldn’t shy away from open, honest and difficult conversations with their kids about these topics.”
Source: Beata Mostafavi – University of Michigan
Publisher: Organized by NeuroscienceNews.com.
Image Source: NeuroscienceNews.com image is adapted from the University of Michigan news release.
Original Research: Abstract for “13 Reasons Why: Viewing Patterns and Perceived Impact Among Youths at Risk of Suicide” by Victor Hong, M.D., Cynthia J. Ewell Foster, Ph.D., Christina S. Magness, L.M.S.W., Taylor C. McGuire, B.S., Patricia K. Smith, M.S., and Cheryl A. King, Ph.D. in Psychiatric Services. Published November 20 2018.
doi:10.1176/appi.ps.201800384
[cbtabs][cbtab title=”MLA”]University of Michigan”Does Netflix ’13 Reasons Why’ Influence Teen Suicide.” NeuroscienceNews. NeuroscienceNews, 20 November 2018.
<https://neurosciencenews.com/13-reasons-why-teen-suicide-10236/>.[/cbtab][cbtab title=”APA”]University of Michigan(2018, November 20). Does Netflix ’13 Reasons Why’ Influence Teen Suicide. NeuroscienceNews. Retrieved November 20, 2018 from https://neurosciencenews.com/13-reasons-why-teen-suicide-10236/[/cbtab][cbtab title=”Chicago”]University of Michigan”Does Netflix ’13 Reasons Why’ Influence Teen Suicide.” https://neurosciencenews.com/13-reasons-why-teen-suicide-10236/ (accessed November 20, 2018).[/cbtab][/cbtabs]
Abstract
13 Reasons Why: Viewing Patterns and Perceived Impact Among Youths at Risk of Suicide
Objective:
The streaming series 13 Reasons Why generated controversy because of its depiction of teen suicide and concerns about its impact on vulnerable youths. This study examined exposure to and patterns of engagement with the show and the show’s perceived impact in a sample of youths presenting to a psychiatric emergency department (ED) with suicide-related concerns in the year after the series’ premiere.
Methods:
Participants were 87 parent-youth dyads (youths’ mean±SD age=14.6±1.8; 71% of youths were female, 26% male, and 2% gender nonconforming) who completed a battery of questionnaires during their ED visit.
Results:
Half (49%) of the sample viewed at least one episode of 13 Reasons Why, season 1. Most youths (84%) viewed the show alone and were more likely to discuss their reactions with peers (80%) than with a parent (34%). Over half of youth viewers (51%) believed the series increased their suicide risk to a nonzero degree; having a stronger identification with the lead female character was significantly related to this belief (r=.63, df=41, p<0.001). Youths with more depressive symptoms and suicidal ideation were more likely to identify with the lead characters and report negative affect while viewing.
Conclusions:
To date, this is the first published study examining viewing patterns and reactions to 13 Reasons Why in a high-risk sample. Although further research is needed, the findings suggest a particular vulnerability to the show’s themes among youths at risk of suicide and the importance of prevention strategies to ameliorate risk among these viewers.
